Most of the users here are basically smarter than typical metal listeners, but I doubt for an instant everyone here agrees what is good and what isn't. There are albums you like that prozak hates, albums that Cynical the editor of the neo-classical section hates that prozak loves, albums that Falco hates that snoop likes and so on. Who decideds what stays and what goes? Anus staff? You guys already have the DLA and this forum.
What is the point of that wiki if it is just to mirror this forum and this website. Is it just a toy for us to play with?