100% Metal Forum (Death Metal and Black Metal)

Metal => Interzone => Topic started by: metalover on October 09, 2007, 06:56:58 PM

Title: HELP need to write an essay on metal
Post by: metalover on October 09, 2007, 06:56:58 PM
I need to write a research paper and decided to pick it on metal, but I have no idea how to struture the essay. What are good genres/subjects to explore? So far i was thinking about:

Genres such as death, black, doom,etc
Sex and religion (male vs female vocals, Satanism, Christanity,)
Exploration of influenational bands. (which ones are the most influencial, i'm not sure, help me out)
any other topics of interest please suggest
as this paper needs to be 9 to 15 pages long

Thanks!
Title: Re: HELP need to write an essay on metal
Post by: Agni on October 09, 2007, 09:03:53 PM
Considering your post (which reveals your knowledge of 'metal'), you should change the topic.

If you wanna learn properly then read this http://anus.com/metal/about/history along with other stuff in the site:
Title: Re: HELP need to write an essay on metal
Post by: AttheGates1996 on October 09, 2007, 09:13:17 PM
i think you should stick to genres as the main paragraphs and topics... discuss in the main paragraphs its origin, and in supporting paragraphs use influential bands as examples of its progression.

-intro to metal in general
-thesis of different genres (heavy, thrash, speed, death, black, contemporary nu metal sellout shit)
-heavy metal
-black sabbath
-iron maiden
-judas priest
-i cant think of any others right now
-thrash
-im not educated in this genre, research. probably mostly hardcore old-school punk
-speed
-metallica
-slayer
-death
-death
-i dont know, theres a large selection to choose from
-black
-i have no clue

... well i hope that helped you some... you could also trying putting in collaborations and other musical genres that branches from these such as "speed-death" "hardcore thrash" "punk-black" and my favorite "ambient death/black"
Title: Re: HELP need to write an essay on metal
Post by: Skjold on October 09, 2007, 09:31:48 PM
Considering you don't know which bands are influential I think I will agree with Agni and suggest you change your topic. Of course, you could see this as an exercise in learning, and investigate it thoroughly. Just don't go on forums asking for people to do your assignments for you, do some proper research.
Title: Re: HELP need to write an essay on metal
Post by: GreatBlackJoy on October 10, 2007, 01:01:02 AM
There is a great wealth of information about metal on the ANUS website, as others have mentioned.

My suggestion to you would be to download the peer to peer filesharing program Soulseek, and use that as an aid to understanding the things you find in the metal archives.

If I were you, I'd set aside 3 or 4 days to seriously digest everything.
Title: Re: HELP need to write an essay on metal
Post by: Horrific Prophecies on October 10, 2007, 01:14:37 AM
Pretty sure I know who 'metalover' is.
http://www.anus.com/metal/hall/YaBB.cgi?board=deathmetal;action=display;num=1191145050;start=30
Title: Re: HELP need to write an essay on metal
Post by: NEVR4GETLOL on October 10, 2007, 02:46:59 AM
Does your name mean "metal lover" or "metal over"?
Title: Re: HELP need to write an essay on metal
Post by: on October 10, 2007, 02:58:43 AM
meta lover?
Title: Re: HELP need to write an essay on metal
Post by: ......... on October 10, 2007, 07:48:42 AM
Suggested reading before you start:

Heavy Metal FAQ: Introduction to Metal Music and Culture (http://www.anus.com/metal/about/faq/)

The Philosophy of Heavy Metal (http://www.anus.com/metal/about/philosophy/)
Title: Re: HELP need to write an essay on metal
Post by: Prospero on October 10, 2007, 05:45:56 PM
I would not start seperating all those bands in genres and talking about those specific genres, you'll get lost in descriptions and all that stuff. You'll end up talking about fuck all while you should talk about the whole metal philosophy. There's only two metal genres. What's good and what is not.

I agree with the other posts, read about metal on ANUS, there are some good articles. You can also go to your library and rent some books on the subject. If you live in a big city you may find the "Sound of the Beast" by Ian Christie or "Into the Pandemonium" by Tom G. Fischer. Otherwise buy them. They worth it!
Title: Re: HELP need to write an essay on metal
Post by: born for banning on October 10, 2007, 05:51:56 PM
Quote
Genres such as death, black, doom,etc
Sex and religion (male vs female vocals, Satanism, Christanity,)
Exploration of influenational bands. (which ones are the most influencial, i'm not sure, help me out)


These are topic areas, not topics. Pick a topic.

Is metal romanticist? Is metal Satanic, or is its Satanism a metaphor? Is metal hateful, or selectively hateful? Is doom metal an attempt to make us feel doom, to warn us of doom, or to encourage us to have values to cope with the doom?

That would be more interesting. You could always do a PC paper about women in metal, minorities in metal (I'd focus on Hispanics, they're the most interesting) and gays in metal, or gender imagery in metal, but then you'd be less of a real person and more of a plastic cutout.

(http://www.rogerson.com.au/boardgames/images/100_3665.jpg)
Title: Re: HELP need to write an essay on metal
Post by: metalover on October 10, 2007, 06:03:24 PM
well i wanted to put the influeniation bands but wasnt really sure i have some knowledge of that though, not totally clueless

death metal: (growled) dark tranquillity, arch enemy, in flames. (grunt) cannibal corpse, decide

black: mayhem, emperor, darkthrone, dimmu,

thrash: slayer, metallica, megadeath

kind of a lot of info if i go into the other types

just maybe need some organization help and guidance is all

thanks for all the replies btw
Title: Re: HELP need to write an essay on metal
Post by: AttheGates1996 on October 10, 2007, 06:24:50 PM
After all being said, Iím still stickin to what I originally said. Everyone elses ideas seem to involve metal but not necessarily focus on it. In my opinion it is much more interesting to explain the different genres of metal and their origins and influence. Afterall, its what makes the metal what it is.
Title: Re: HELP need to write an essay on metal
Post by: esoteric on October 10, 2007, 06:34:09 PM
What kind of essay are you requested to write? Descriptive essays are often boring, so if it's open ended, write an argumentative one. People don't want to read long descriptions of the facets of all the different genres if they're not already interested in it - would you want to read someone's essay talking about the differences between trance techno and drum & bass?

Pick a popular conceptualization of metal and refute it or clarify it - for example, that it is talentless or violent. Is this true? Is it a good or bad thing? If it's false, what is the true position and why? Why should/shouldn't a disinterested person be interested in metal? These are the questions people are interested in - use a broad field of research to answer them and convince them you are right. Good luck!
Title: Re: HELP need to write an essay on metal
Post by: ......... on October 10, 2007, 06:46:44 PM
No matter what you do, don't rule out Burzum if you're going to write about black metal. I remember I was horrified when I saw Sam Dunn had put down Cradle of Filth as Norwegian Black Metal, and not Burzum ::)
Title: Re: HELP need to write an essay on metal
Post by: oogaa on October 10, 2007, 07:24:01 PM
Sam Dunn? All he did was make a neatly packaged, bubblegum documentary just so that it'd would be platable to everyone.  I mean what credibility would a person have when he devotes a good 20-25 minutes to feature  the groupies  and the cock-rock scene in a so called 'metal documentary'?

Title: Re: HELP need to write an essay on metal
Post by: death metal black metal on October 10, 2007, 07:29:13 PM
Quote
If you're one of the real threats to this board, the moronic false elitists who bolster their sagging self-confidence by putting down others and thus making themselves happy, go to church! Your false elitism is the flip side of pity and really, I'd rather have you be a Christian so you might at least do some good instead of sitting on your internet throne and congratulating yourselves for being so intelligent.


- Some metal nerd (http://www.anus.com/metal/hall/YaBB.cgi?board=metal_talk;action=display;num=1179762189)
Title: Re: HELP need to write an essay on metal
Post by: Prospero on October 11, 2007, 03:39:19 AM
Quote
No matter what you do, don't rule out Burzum if you're going to write about black metal. I remember I was horrified when I saw Sam Dunn had put down Cradle of Filth as Norwegian Black Metal, and not Burzum ::)


Yes, I saw that too, they are not even Norwegian!... All joking aside, to me, Burzum is the most authentic, influencial and important black metal band out there.

Although I don't like black metal (aside from Filosofem and a few black metal-minded ambient artistst), I read about him, on his website notably, and the only reason why Sam Dunn did not mentioned Burzum was because of controversy. He sure knew the band.

The rest of his documentary was sure interesting but when he got into more complex stuff, death and black metal, he fucked up. Dickinson, Dio and Lemmy were great interviews but Lamb Of God and Slipknot... That was sad (remember when Slipknot said "You cannot think of an inverted cross without thinking of Black Sabbath" - they are Christian you dumbasses!). They have not credits for anything in metal whatsoever, but you guys know that...

Poor Sam Dunn who I though would make a good documentary when he started naming some of his favorite stuff (Beneath The Remains, Autopsy, etc.). Perhaps somebody hold him back on interviewing Varg Vikernes...
Title: Re: HELP need to write an essay on metal
Post by: Agni on October 12, 2007, 09:06:08 PM
Quote
well i wanted to put the influeniation bands but wasnt really sure i have some knowledge of that though, not totally clueless

death metal: (growled) dark tranquillity, arch enemy, in flames. (grunt) cannibal corpse, decide

black: mayhem, emperor, darkthrone, dimmu,

thrash: slayer, metallica, megadeath


concentrate on the names in bold and you'll do just fine