Thrones of Heresy – Realms of Desecration

thrones_of_heresy-realms_of_desecrationThe existence of modern death metal — the merging of multiple genres together and slapping the veneer of death metal over it should result in a product that does not appeal to any of the fans of the individual genres, as they will always have purer distillations of each type of metal available — fascinates me. Nevertheless, the genre exists and is evidently quite popular with someone, as numerous bands in the genre arise all the time and reach some measure of success.

Throne of Heresy is such a band, and is an able defender of this type of composition: any type of metal that has been popular over the past two decades is thrown into a blender and the result is a competent but stylistically confused product. Each section of the tracks is well-composed and well executed , though what’s lacking is any sense of purpose or meaning. The progenitors of each style of metal represented here had an intention behind their work, a desire to create art that is conspicuously absent on this EP.

Featuring a decidedly verse-chorus structure, the songs consist of tonally ambiguous palm-muted riffs morphing into admittedly catchy choruses that give way to whatever School of Metal technique is the flavor of the day: it could be a “melodic” solo, an awkward semi-clean breakdown, or perhaps even a key change. What makes these sectional divides even more jarring is that there is very little in the song to indicate when they are occurring, or indeed why they are occurring.

This is not to give the impression that there is nothing of merit occurring: the vocals on the whole are solid death metal belts, though on times they do take on the angry for the sake of being angry tinge that is ingrained in modern metal. Each of the instruments is composed and played well, but the lack of intention or drive that so characterizes modern metal creates an obstacle that cannot be overcome.

It seems to me that bands such as this are suffering from an identity crisis: they are trying to appeal to fans of every genre of metal. While this may be a sound financial decision, it is not a good artistic decision, which is a shame as there is definitely a core of talent to be explored here.

Tags: , ,

3 thoughts on “Thrones of Heresy – Realms of Desecration

  1. bitterman says:

    This is what happens when Ozzfest attendees (Devil Driver fans) see Kataklysm for the first time, find out it’s “death metal”, discover Unique Leader records back catalogue through a few google searches the next day and decide to make a band combining the two via Facebook a month later.

  2. fallot says:

    Wonderfully written

  3. The Deciever says:

    Is there only room for niche bands in todays music industry? I remember the good old days where bands could be pretty diverse and still be popular, for example Metallica. I agree that if its *too* unfocused or the songwriting under par that its another issue. Personally I get pretty bored of most niche bands pretty quick. Either they have like 1-2 good songs per album or the songs is more of the same you just heard.

Comments are closed.

Classic reviews: