Sadistic Metal Reviews 11-24-13


What are Sadistic Metal Reviews? These reviews address the music itself, instead of the social impact of assembling a public persona out of bands you claim to like. Since almost all human endeavors are mostly mediocrity, there will be tender self-pity follow by rage. Come for the laughs, stay for the schadenfreude… and occasional quality metal.

dissect-swallow_swouming_massDissect – Swallow Swouming Mass

Another band that leaves an “I guess it’s OK” impression, Dissect is interchangeable early 90s death metal. The deep vocals, downtuned guitars, and atmosphere are all there, but it’s unnecessary in light of other bands doing this style better. Unless you’re curious as to what Gorefest’s Mindloss would sound like if dumbed down into commercial jingles for Benediction fans, it’s best to leave this one alone. Like most bands from the Netherlands, the music is mediocre, but at least the lyrics are unintentionally funny.

philip_h_anselmo_and_the_illegals-walk_through_exists_onlyPhilip H. Anselmo & the Illegals – Walk Through Exits Only

This has all the hallmarks of Anselmo. The bird squawking vocals, stupid lyrics, and the music sounds like a hip-hop parody of bluegrass given a RAWK makeover are all there, except taken to the EXTREME with blast beats and tremolo picked riffs. Who’s he fooling with this? It still sounds like Pantera with the addition of randomness. The soundtrack to wearing an Anthrax shirt and skipping bail in a pickup truck while smoking a lot of meth after beating up your wife and step kids while a Steve Wilkos marathon is playing in the background.

shitfucker-suck_cocks_in_hellShitfucker – Suck Cocks in Hell

This is basically a hardcore band, with some stylings of heavy metal and black metal. Thus, expect sawing droning high-energy riffs, but with the fills of an Americanized NWOBHM band and occasional black metal vocals or melodic sweep-riffs in the Gorgoroth/Emperor style. However, for the most part this is a middle period hardcore band, sounding like a more spacious version of the Dayglo Abortions. It’s not bad but not compelling.

rottrevore-hung_by_the_eyesocketsRottrevore – Hung by the Eyesockets

Some bands just shouldn’t reform, especially third rate death metal bands from the 90s. Rottrevore return, playing their Harmony Corruption with Craig Pillard vocals form of death metal, but has regressed to a point where there’s no consistency in these songs which randomly showcase “old school” cliches. The typical 90s death metal of these riffs are a placeholder for a “mosh” or “breakdown” part which suggests this band may have been influenced by Pantera and/or metalcore during their time off. Still, about the only thing this band has done that’s of any note is having a member temporarily join Incantation in the mid 90s.

wombbath-internal_caustic_tormentsWombbath – Internal Caustic Torments

This band creates old school death metal with the vocal rhythms and tempo changes of Hypocrisy, but the storming intensity of an American death metal band like Massacre hybridized with the more percussive riffing of the second album from Suffocation. It is too good to remain a local band; however, there’s a reason (besides the goofy name) why this band never rose above the level of second-tier with bands like Utumno, Uncanny and Obscurity. It is highly rhythmic but repetitive both in riff use and song structure without much melodic development, which makes the experience of listening to it about like listening to a wall. There is a verse/chorus loop which is broken up with riffs for texture, and some melodic lead riffing which bounces over the thundering chords, but beyond that the story doesn’t develop much. Some of the later songs show a greater appetite for adventure, but there’s too much of a reek of wanting to be like Entombed with the more basic and thunderous attack of Obscurity, which removed a lot of what made Swedish death metal exciting in the first place which was its use of melody and dynamics. I don’t mind listening to this, but I’m unlikely to pick it up except as a curio of the past.

equinox-of_blade_and_graalEquinox – Of Blade and Graal

This EP begins with a Graveland-cum-neofolk style chanted introduction over acoustic guitar and then launches into three tracks of savage black metal. This band shows a lot of promise, but has two major beginner’s thwarts standing in its way: first, it is unclear on what style it wants to be, ranging between Iron Maiden heavy metal and Graveland black metal and back again with some stoner doom and Danzigish riffs; second, it doesn’t complete songs. These aren’t journeys from A->B, but journeys from A-> to a conceptual space where we think about the many possibilities that might be B. As a result, much like on a GBK record, the listener gets the feeling of something started but losing momentum in indecision. The good with Equinox is that these riffs tend to be very creative and fairly technical in a way you don’t normally hear, which is that they have complexity of phrase and within that, of rhythm, more like a jazz band or a solo. Like many black metal albums, these three tracks cluster themes which are revisited across song boundaries, creating a sense of being caught in one longer song. The lack of landmarks and destinations confuses it however, as does the jumble of styles, including one riff lifted from the first COC album. However, this demo shows a great deal of promise and as the band contemplates it over time, may be the inception of greater things to follow.

hate_storm_annihilation-storm_of_flamesHate Storm Annihilation – Storm of Flames

Despite the rather war-metalish name, HSA is middle period death metal; think late 1990s Sinister crossed with Malevolent Creation from the same period. Good riff diversity and variety, and song structure that holds together while allowing an interplay between elements to emerge, distinguish this approach from the soulless one-dimensionality to follow. Stylistically, there is not much new here, but these guys have their own voice in the content of the song, which is a somewhat pensive approach like early Darkthrone or Infester with a bit more intensity thrown in out of verge. While this is only one song, and the band has a horrible low-IQ name, here’s hoping they’ll produce more in the future.

monastyr-never_dreamingMonastyr – Never Dreaming

Sub-par Polish chug death metal that reduces the NYDM style into being bouncy mosh fodder. The death/grind that Unique Leader would later popularize in the 2000s through Deprecated and Disgorge is found here sandwiched between Deicide style rhythms going into Massacre styled bouncy riffs. It’s like an over-produced and over-long death metal demo from 1994 which sounds like an aesthetically upgraded version of what bands like Benediction and Cancer were producing around this time. So, more vacuous “middle of the road” death metal that accomplishes nothing beyond being vacuous “brutal mosh metal” and as such, unnecessary beyond a one time use as background music.

convulse-reflectionsConvulse – Reflections

Convulse release an album that is arguably their most well-written, but it’s also aesthetically maladjusted and void of artistic merit. Leaving their Bolt Thrower meets Benediction rudimentary “mosh” death metal behind for the death n’ roll trend of Entombed and Xysma, Convulse make a fully functional rock album with great instrumentation and performances. The problem is the gimmickry. A whimsically folky intro does a poor job setting the stage for the album proper, which is a more sufficiently mainstream version of the Xysma and Amorphis albums from this period. Extreme vocals, drums, and happy jazzy riffs are tremolo picked and blasted through giving this the feeling of death metal musicians parodying radio music more than anything. Bluesy and psychedelic as well, it seems like Convulse’s talent for stealing their country mates ideas has culminated in an album that simultaneously does everything their peers strove for better but coming off more poor in making things work cohesively as a listening experience, revealing this to be more of a “quirky” sham born from a conformist outlook than anything honest.

dead_world-the_machineDead World – The Machine

Early “death industrial” band Dead World uses the Streetcleaner formula for aesthetics but is closer to monotonic and mechanical industrial music in their compositions than anything that could be called metal. Lyrics and the “broodingly moody” manner in which they’re delivered reflect the mentality that Nine Inch Nails and Marilyn Manson would use when making pop-industrial themed Xanax accompaniments. The band does a good job of making the downtuned guitars, vocals, and drums work together into making a “hostile” soundscape, but it’s really monotonous stomping rhythms are only interrupted by discordant bridges that don’t build on any of the preceding and the music doesn’t unfold through layers of guitar tracks, making this a bite-sized version of the Godflesh style that is more in line with what mainstream industrial rock bands were shipping out at this time. Very obvious “misanthropic” heavy rock music that doesn’t offer anything over its clone target.

Daniel Rodriguez, Jon Wild, Max Bloodworth and Cory Van Der Pol contributed to this report.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

17 thoughts on “Sadistic Metal Reviews 11-24-13”

  1. eman says:

    Only album I have heard from this list is by Dissect. Thought it was pretty good, will listen again. Probably won’t check out any others.

    Anelmo review was pretty good…

  2. BJ says:

    Some suggested albums (kindle?) for Sadistic Metal Reviews:

    * 1349 – Hellfire
    * 1349 – Liberation
    * Arch Enemy – Wages of Sin
    * Arcturus – La Masquerade Infernale
    * Arcturus – The Sham Mirrors
    * Between the Buried and Me – Colors
    * The Black Dahlia Murder – Unhallowed
    * Cattle Decapitation – Humanure
    * Children of Bodom – Follow the Reaper
    * Children of Bodom – Hatebreeder
    * Children of Bodom – Something Wild
    * Cryptopsy – Once Was Not
    * Deicide – The Stench of Redemption
    * The Dillinger Escape Plan – Calculating Infinity
    * The Dillinger Escape Plan – Miss Machine
    * Dream Theater – Awake
    * Dream Theater – Images and Words
    * Dream Theater – Metropolis, Pt. 2: Scenes from a Memory
    * Dream Theater – Train of Thought
    * Ensiferum – Ensiferum
    * Ensiferum – Iron
    * Gorgoroth – Ad Majorem Sathanas Gloriam
    * Hypocrisy – The Arrival
    * Hypocrisy – Hypocrisy
    * Hypocrisy – Virus
    * Impaled Nazarene – Nihil
    * In Flames – Whoracle
    * Kalmah – Swamplord
    * Kalmah – Swampsong
    * Kalmah – They Will Return
    * Mayhem – Chimera
    * Meshuggah – I
    * Naglfar – Diabolical
    * Nocturnus – The Key
    * Norther – Death Unlimited
    * Norther – Dreams of Endless War
    * Opeth – Damnation
    * Opeth – My Arms, Your Hearse
    * Pig Destroyer – Terrifyer
    * Satyricon – The Shadowthrone
    * Slipknot – Slipknot
    * Venom – Black Metal
    * Wintersun – Wintersun

    1. puzzled says:

      Chimera and The Key? How does either album deserve getting sadistically reviewed? And I think Opeth and Satyricon have taken enough punishment for a lifetime, however well-deserved it may be: eventually it just gets boring.

      1. BJ says:

        Good points. I’m not saying those albums are necessarily “bad” (I in fact own a copy of THE KEY and find some of songs enjoyable) but SMR includes not only the failures, but also efforts that are decent but are not quite up to elite standard. Near-misses, in other words (cf. the Shitfucker review [“It’s not bad but not compelling”] and all of the Satyricon reviews). Also, I find SMR to be edifying as it is entertaining; by pointing out what’s “wrong” with an album, each review is like a concise lesson in how not to write songs.


    Wait. So does that mean that bands like: Convulse, Benediction, Cancer, Wombbath and Rottrevore are not good enough? Man! I always believed their early material would be at least worthy of a completist. Am I delusional??

    1. fenrir says:

      Read what he said about Wombbath again… he said it is good, deserves to be international, it’s just not great.
      Besides you should have your own judgement…

    2. fallot says:

      No, their early material is worthy of a completist. So is a lot of worse stuff.

  4. EDS says:

    The review of the Wombbath album is spot on. Not at all worth buying (has it been re-issued?) or tracking down on E-bay. However is serves as good warm up material to get one going on a nighttime metal binge. And true, the later songs on the album are better. Try their demo, Brutal Mights if you want some Finn-death styled songs with flow and lots of tremolos. It’s actually a decent listen, plus the best song from the full length, Beyond the Gloomy appears on that demo.

    I always wanted to listen to that Convulse album despite knowing it was a bit death & roll. I’m going to check it out still as I want to hear this bands whole musical progression. I second the review of that Rottrevore EP. Utter garbage.

  5. paul says:

    I really liked Rottrevore’s old album for its production and atmosphere, although the riffs and songs were nothing spectacular. Disappointed to hear the new EP isn’t much up to scruff, I’ll have to give it a listen sometime.

  6. parasite says:

    The Wombbath album is awesome! totally WORTH buying and they better reissue it!

  7. EDS says:

    Rottrevore’s full length is one of my all time favorite death metal albums. From the production to the riffs and the vocals, to me everything sounds great. I am a huge fan of the songwriting and the album never lets up. The Wombbath album should be streamed prior to a decision to buy or not is made. Some may enioy their style of percussive riffing and repetitive song writing but the songs come across as slightly bland to me especially for 1993 standards. All in all its cool to listen to every now and then…

  8. walter says:

    you can pick up the Wombbath CD quite easily. got mine from dark descent for $10 quite recently.

  9. Jennifer T says:

    My husband plays in Rottrevore.

    1. fenrir says:

      I like to eat strawberries with chocolate.

      Any other stand-alone statements that go nowhere?

      1. kvlt attakker says:

        I have one.

        You’re rather rude.

      2. Jennifer T says:


  10. Orville says:

    HSA is from Chicago and I’ve heard them at the HOB amazing…. Death Metal Duo. You say “No way” but I’m telling you these two guys get it done. Other bands come on with 4,5,6, guys/girls and they don’t get it done. Hope to see them soon again. I have heard the song “From the Inside Out” on their Reverb page. Brutal also.

Comments are closed.

Classic reviews: